Pool Net vs Pool Fence: Which One Is Better? An Honest Review

pool fencing laws South Australia

What makes a pool safety net different from a pool safety fence? We will go through all the benefits and drawbacks of each, as well as provide you with an accurate cost estimate if you are planning to get one across South Australia.

Parents, schools, and communities all around the world rely on swimming pool fences and pool covers. Most drowning prevention groups as well as the government instated pool inspection and fencing laws encourage implementing numerous layers of protection, but the barricade you choose to keep your children safe should be the one you feel 100% reliant upon. Here are some factors to consider when deciding between a pool safety fence and a pool safety net.

What are the Pros and Cons of The Pool Safety Net?

The pool nets are designed primarily to act as a barrier between children and open water. The net appears exactly like an oversized tennis racket and is extended across the pool and secured to deck-flush mounted bolts.


  • The proven safety record for 100% prevention of drowning
  • You can have complete peace of mind that you are covered from all kinds of dangers
  • Amazing aesthetic appeal to maximise yard space while keeping a clear view of the water
  • Is available in various ambient colours to go with your backyard
  • Comes with an optional leaf cover to prevent seasonal debris accumulation
  • It is one of the least invasive safety installation processes
  • A flexible option that can be accommodated to nearly all water features


  • Pool covering requires a manual effort that might take around 8 minutes to replace and 5 minutes to remove
  • Needs to meet ASTM F1346-91building code standards


What are the Pros and Cons of the Pool Safety Fence?

Pool fencing is available in a wide variety of styles and options that provides a vertical layer of security around your pool. A pool fence allows you to get to your pool quickly and easily. The mesh pool panel options are resilient against moulds, abrasion, and extreme heat. So, they won’t shred, shrink, or fade, and children will not be able to push through them.


  • Highly attractive and are available in natural colours
  • Can be integrated into your existing structures thus reducing costs
  • Allows swift and convenient entrance to your pool


  • Invasive installation process
  • Less flexibility when it comes to routing options
  • If the fence Is infiltrated, there are no more additional barriers left between the child and the water
  • ASTM F2286-16 compliance is required to comply with the pool fencing laws in South Australia


A pool safety net will usually cost a quarter of the price of an isolation fence (A fence that encircles the pool entirely). A pool safety net might cost around $1500.00 to $2200.00 for a standard pool, including all parts, tax, and installation. Due to various configurations, colour and height options, pool fencing prices can be a bit complicated.

Pool Safety Fence vs. Pool Safety Net

Putting all that aside, all water safety experts will agree that the best way to keep your children safe in swimming pools is to have an adult supervise them at all times and to implement multiple layers of security. So, whether you choose to surround your pool with a pool fencing system or cover it with a pool net, or both, make sure your barrier is kept in good working order at all times, with covers securely replaced and pool gates closed and key-locked after each swim.